"The show keeps many secrets and presents many twists, most of which caught the audience by great surprise... Expect laughter and suspense as the mystery slowly and craftily unravels."
Dutch Godshalk, Montgomery Newspapers
"It's about as intelligent, fanciful, and witty a Holmes as you can find on the stage anywhere this summer."
Manchester Journal
"Simply delicious describes perfectly the comedy in the Dorset Theatre Festival's Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Jersey Lily, the Katie Forgette mystery-comedy that opened at the Dorset Playhouse Friday. And it was a pretty neat mystery too....You simply remain on edge—when you're not laughing."
Times Argus
"A faithful, loving tribute to the colorful British characters of Sherlock Holmes and Oscar Wilde, Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Jersey Lily by Seattle playwright Katie Forgette fancifully fuses fact and fiction."
Jonathan Turner, Quad-Cities Online
"Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Jersey Lily remembers a time when detective stories were not about blood and bodies, but brains and bon mots."
Kevin Prokosh, Winnipeg Free Press
"If you've been hankering for a right jolly bit of theatrical sleuthing British style, you'd be hard put to it, indeed, to ferret out better fare than Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Jersey Lily..."
Herald Courier
"...a quick-paced, witty...confection that goes down like iced lemonade on a summer scorcher."
Pioneer Press
"Sherlock is all about fun, and supplies it in good measure."
Minneapolis City Pages
"Holmes has 'lock' on comedy..."
Star Tribune
"Katie Forgette's delicious take on the great detective...is a delightful theatrical romp as Holmes and Watson join forces with Oscar Wilde to protect the actress Lillie Langtry."
Philly.com
"This production ultimately emerges as a wonderful family-friendly evening of theater. There is comedy, drama, even a second-act swordfight, all wrapped in the familiar faces of Holmes, Watson, and Wilde."
Nicholas Martorellia, Stage Magazine Online
"Sherlock fans are in for a treat... If this is amusing for audiences, you can only imagine how entertaining it is for the actors... All told: delish."
Toby Zinman, The Philadelphia Inquirer